I have often been accused of being an idealist by my diatribes against this or that. By itself I do not take that as an insult, but for the fact that the quasi-intellectual snob issuing the diss is so enamored with the dog eat dog principle that he/she/it can only focus on the diss and nothing more.
Fact: we are sinking! Despite the massive amounts of money spent to convince the masses that the failing in education is based on the teacher, with big government - especially the semi-literate president of the last eight years - coming to the rescue, we have seen no improvements in anything but the test scores itself, and yet the rise of dropouts, the rise in remedial college entrance requirements and the sheer useless degrees that are conferred have done nothing to bolster America's place within the global economy. And now, at the height of the recession, we are faced with an ever spiraling decline in potential as we addict our youth to insane, empty pop-culture and the promise that their shielded ego's do not have to break a sweat because they are "special."
Bush claims NCLB as his crowning victory. Victory of what? He has turned the whole system on its ass and achieved nothing; he could not even fully fund the program over his entire two terms.
NCLB is an embarrassment of political victory over intellect. It has generated jobs for no reason; a generation of people pretending to be achieving some tangible that no one can articulate beyond citing "data" as a quantifiably religious experience. The truth is that through NCLB we have allowed politicians and lawyers to hold us back while the world prepares its youth to take over our lead.
We are a nation engulfed in debt, religious dogma that is shrouded in legal protections, all of which inhibits any possible progress. Everyone has a God-given right, so much so that almost everything can be construed an offense against someone's right, requiring endless litigation, consultation and compromise before finally settling on the premise that the needs of the one outweigh the needs of the many. Wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong. Nature would scream that it is survival of the fittest. The weak do not survive in nature. But in America the weak are the cornerstone of the new church of everlasting litigation. Blessed is he with the lawyer for he shall inherit the precedent.
In a recent article in TCR (Teacher's College Record) Charles Murray’s recently released book, Real Education: Four Simple Truths for Bringing America’s Schools Back to Reality, essentially argues that earning a BA is a waste of time for many Americans because they are not able to perform BA-level work due to a lack of intrinsic abilities. Murray’s new book is fruit from the same poison tree that produced his racial theories of intelligence in The Bell Curve, published in 1996. In The Bell Curve, Charles Murray argued that low test scores among minorities were caused more by nature than nurture.
You can read that article HERE. Right or not, we have become a nation obsessed with direct cause and effect relationships. We attribute our education policy to this effect which, in turn, changes generationally, causing a "flavor of the month" fad approach to education practices that serve only to attract intellectually stunted politicians who can latch onto the singular concepts.
In my opinion, the standards serve as a signpost. The skill and the passion of the teacher serve as the power. Unity is found by encouraging not limiting those who have the power to shape and mould a generation. Instead, our political machine and government claims to act in the best interest of education by slapping a set of limits that not only hold back our populace, but start a chain reaction of self-destructive events that ultimately leads to a nation of idiots, degreed and yet unskilled, educated without substance of character because we are afraid of stunting their personas through anything but positive affirmation. We all laughed at Saturday Night Live's Stuart Smalley, and yet we have made that our mantra.
In California we are faced with dire consequences in the bid to find a balanced budget. The state, a fiscal nightmare over the last few generations, has now come to the breaking point; no budget and no money. Amongst the stupid ideas; shortening the school year, issuing IOU's to teachers - who surely can't find a bank to cash those - and adding additional taxes.
In the 1940's, students learned the basics. Simple books that helped cement the skills needed:
reading, writing and arithmetic. Every bureaucrat argues that times are more complex now, and yet despite the complexity, despite the millions of dollars and the revised, standards-based textbooks, we have still not produced a generation of functionally literate students that are proficient at reading, writing and arithmetic. Is it that we cannot make children feel badly for not learning their multiplication facts; or is it that the average student can spell "fuck you" but can't even spell principal (as in their school's principal) or even the word "elementary." Hardly surprising considering that television glorifies sex and violence, whilst music glorifies gangsters, drugs and prison, while religion has been kept busy purging the molesters and crooks, and the leaders of this country spend their time justifying a war on terror they can neither explain, nor evaluate, yet remain certain will continue into the next century.
If I am idealistic, it is my last ditch effort at injecting some sanity into the lunacy we call society. We need no more shopping mall clones. We need no more legal loopholes for corporations and diplomats and politicians who, in another time, may well have been lined against a wall and executed for treason. Legally we are unable to define perjury anymore, and certainly cannot execute our right to purge government of the weak, the greedy and the stupid.
I'll stick to my idealism. I like to believe that despite everything humanity has a measure of good. It is, after all, in the darkest of times that we shine as a species. It seems that it takes disaster to make us rise to the occasion, beyond greed and profit, and actually care that we are one species who, by our own doing, may be rapidly running out of time.
I'm not sure what it will take for people to wake up. It may already be too late. We may already be destined to be the former trustees of this world. I hope not. We just have to stop accepting anything less than integrity and decency, even if that means we pay a little more for our products and pray a little more for our souls.
MisterWriter